… pain comes from ignorance but you do not feel it till knowledge arrives. Tricky, isn’t it?
The main purpouse of this review is to share the point-of-ear of a low budget guy in the search of the best high-end sound possible for a given, and small, amount of money.
I am a young Spanish man living on its own country. That means that despite the recent WEB shops offering you all-that-your-money-can-buy I only have access to less than 25 real-shops all over Spain. Less than 25 places in a 44 million people country where you could go and discover the difference between MP3s played in tiny-little-plastic-chumpky-wannabes-machines over the real meaning behind the word music. Anyway it does not matter, so you won’t find yourself waiting your turn at your nearest hi-end dealer, before that happens something must change into our more than extrange social accepted musical tastes. Never mind… that is another tale and I am lucky enough to live 35 minutes away by car from my closest real-shop.
I have studied electric piano for six years and electronic-design as main studies. I have spent many hours reading about acoustic principles, room treatments and hi-end electronic design notes. I have practical experience working at my own extinct lab but I must confess that this was some years ago so all that I have now is a full-metal suitcase with a soldier inside.
When I got paid for my nearly very first job (second in fact) I spent all my money in a Rotel RA-931 MkII Integrated Amplifier and B&W 601 S3 speakers pair linked by the cheapest VdH cable, bare wire at the ends of course. Source? My Audiotrak Maya soundcard with gold-plated RCAs seemed the best and the only possible choice: class A-weighted outputs at least.
I remember that I was (and still am) a happy audiophile-boy. I discovered what the ‘reference people’ from Stereophile and such media spoke when they write words like ‘space between musical planes’, ‘high and atmospheric soundstage’ and so… I guess that every single current hi-end maniac remember the transition from reading & believing to hearing & discovering. Something deep in your soul wakes up and lifts you forward to ecstassy and the only thing you want is more and more music flooding your new golden ears.
‘Okay, I have taken into the very first step and I want more…’ I said to my self. So next natural move is to improve source moving from the nice soundcard into something better. There was a Rotel RCD-961 HDCD player under a dust cover at my local dealer and it was another monthly payment burning in my budget. So my ears were kicked up again, music in a higher concentration filled my ears and run throught my veins. I discovered that it really does not matter if you extract music fron an original CD by error correction reading process and compress with MP3 320Kbps in natural stereo (who the hell invented joint-stereo music torturing algorithm?). Every single CD played at the Rotel spinner sounded better than the very best MP3 and I was happy to feel the difference with my cheap ride electronic system. One particular noticeable difference was A/B swapping test from Celtic female vocals singing over clean strings background: Rotel CD places the woman and the guitar in two separate places, MP3 sticks woman inside the guitar.
‘Well, well, well… we are going in the right direction. What else can I do?’ Ummm…. this VdH cheap cables… next month my VISA number made a web flashing trip to the Britain Island and one week after I was plugging a quarter of my monthly payment between the amp and the kevlar ones. QED 25th Ann Bi-Wire with Airloc connections. This investment were translated into a less impressive improvement, anyway there was some great changes: cleaner and more analytical sound brings out from the yellow buddies and some heavy fabric seems to be removed between them and me.
Now, 5 years after, I live at my own house so I cannot still spend my whole pay at my poor and sick dealer. In fact I feel lucky just when I am able to buy some new CD so next move was carefully planned even when I must admit that all began from an unwanted experience.
It was more than one year ago from now when I was sitting between a pair of Dynaudio Audience 52 plugged throught Occos’ to a nice Copland hybrid amp. That was the perfect stereo match for the money choosen by one of my very best friends. I remember that I was typing in the computer placed in front of the stereo so I could not see my buddy’s dirty strategy, such a malign plan that would let me again in the stereo depression of hearing something so much better that your brain will never forget. I was used to hear is fairly better equipment and this had never made me bored when turning back to my modest British-Japan cheap colleagues. Suddenly this day something different hit my ears. I just stop typing when some trance-dance music reach my ears, there was nothing about the score or the music itself, there was something different in the sound, the recording was so organic and live-like that my brain instantly relaxed falling into a sweet neural-trance-dance state… ‘Wow!!!! That is THE absolute recording I have never ever heard!!!!’ My friend start laughing… ‘Turn back!’ – he said. At first sight I did not see what he wanted to show me ‘What…??’ – I asked… but there was no further explanation request. Placed next to the Copland amp there was a 20 years old turntable playing a new vinyl Slash recording. I had read before about sound-stress brain throuble when you listen to digital recorded music but it was the very first time that I noticed what they were talking about. ‘Oh no! Holly crap!’ – I swear while my friend kept laughing, he knew that the stylus had hit really deep in my heart.
That was at the end of 2.007, my next birthday was Feb 2008 and I was wondering if my dear and beloved friends would remember about this story which I truly emphasized by sending an email to everybody explaining how reveailing the vynil experience had been. The happy day arrived and I got a flat and square present, 140g Art Balkey Moanin’ record was my first brand new sealed vynil but I was not blessed with the proper machinery so instead of a nice turntable I get a pair of motorbike boots, well… fate laughted again but my feet were warm. So I have to store the Moanin’ record and start saving some bucks for something good and worth. One year later my savings for that purpouse remained close to the absolute nothing definition from the outer space void so I tried my last chance: VISA.
The right turntable for the money, the best and safe investment seemed to be Rega P3 with the Elys cartridge fitted and its nice RB300 arm which looks like the bigbros RB700, but it was too much for one single vynil collection and too much for the first try. Remember that at this point vynil sound was just hard to forget: one song experience from more than twelve months before.
Project Debut III at 250€ was a three times cheaper choice than the P3 and the most important: I was able to listen to it at my local dealer, it was matched with Prima Luna Prologue Two and Vintage Sonus Faber, I cannot remember the cable but it was something really thick, a trully impressive red and black snake which should cost more than the speakers themselves.
I listen to very different music styles so if you want to enjoy playing The White Stripes and Korsakov on the same hifi system you will never find your audio nirvana on such a laid-back sound from matching tubes with non-high efficiente speakers like de S.F. Vintages. It sounded like trying to breathe under the water the cheap turntable was showing some of what was recorded at my sould more than one year before. ‘I want it’ – I said. But it was the only one so I had to wait 48 hours for a box sealed unit. ‘Pack it! I am taking away the demo one; 48 hours was too much waiting after such a long time. Five minutes after I was driving with the Pro-Ject box seated and belted at my side along a new Bad vynil record from Mr. Jacko, nice present from my dealer.
Once at home I plug it right into my Rotel 931 MkII MM Phono stage and the Bad guy start spinning, on the HDCD Rotel 961 CD player I played right the same record for A/B switching: Another part of me is like every Quincy/M.J. session a clean recording master lesson with everything right placed but you are still missing something if you have not heared it from vynil yet. Highs are not stressing, guitars have some articulated and natural feeling and rythm flows direct to your soul. Well, well, well… Lesson number one: my new turntable performs better than a three times more expensive CD player. I was surprised that the poor noise/signal rate from the turntable did not blur or ruin the listening experience. Lesson number two: analogue noise is not the same than digital noise.
‘Let’s spin some serious stuff!!’ I said to myself while I remove Bad and stick the Art Balkley record, I let the stylus fall and I jump to my sofa just before the first notes blow my heart away.
This was the most stunning listening experience I had ever heard: forget about my Copland / Dynaudio friend gear, forget about B&W 801 Nautilus / Krell 5kw, forget everything singing from a CD. Any of them has absolutely nothing to do against my poor Rotel and cheap B&Ws. Sure that this expensive gear has tons of detail, space, crystal clear highs and round and paced bass but THEY ARE DEATH FROM THE (CD) START!!!!
From that moment I made my up mind and discovered the sad truth behind this psicopatik audiophiles who have never ever listened to vynil or even worse those who still love their CDs for some strange and sick behaviour.
I wanted some better gear, sure, but I would build it right from the coherence of an all-analogue-system.
Once you walk the line and start the pursuit for the perfect sound it’s easy to get lost in the vast world of hi-end trademarks and the infinite technology ocean.
Looking for the perfect loudspeaker? From the simpliest design to the most exotic ones going through horns, ribbons, radial and electrostatics you will find that it’s really easy to get lost, mad or what is even worse: completely, absolutely unhappy with your hifi gear… forever.
After reading and searching through the WEB you find your head full of dBs/M/W, active and passive crossovers, biamping, biwiring and not to mention about what really matters: How the hell do they sound like? Atmosphere, musicality, 3D holographic sound…
Theorically the best speaker must behave as one single sound pulsating point, like the Cabasse Sphere which seems one of the closest to perfection solutions all around, nothing wrong about them except that the price of the speakers and the recommended gear is around $160.000$… Yeah! Anything else for the poor people on a budget?
Once you leave perfection behind (or maybe perfection lets you alone in a dark road to… nowhere?) the game begins, you know that anything else will not be perfect so you should get in mind about making some compromises…. but there is something before the speakers: What about your room? Big room needs big speakers and they need powerful amps and big rooms need expensive wall, roof and floor treatment… well, you get the idea, the bigger rooms the more expensive gear. So think about moving children beds to the living room or build your own hifi-bunker… anywhere because it will be the cheapest and most satisfying sound experience. Small rooms around 3m x 5m would be the best choice but be aware that irregular rooms could offer surprising results as they use to offer the lowest resonance problems. If your are confined into a rectangular space forget about placing the speakers in the short side and sit yourself two times the distance between the speakers. The best stereo placement in small rectangular rooms is to locate the speakers aligned with the long wall….
… well you will find much information around the web but I will take this article towards my present state of mind: maybe some music could work on small rooms played by small and good speakers but if you want to groove while playing big songs no matter which kind are we talking about you will need a huge stage, space, higher than normal cells, big speakers and yes big, hard, unefficient but
fast & tight speakers (I am sorry for that
Mr. Deckert). Sure that even with the best big-gear available you will lose some inner detail and micro-dynamics because of its ineffiency but I.M.O. they are worth the deal.
Cone-drivers still being a great tech for the job but it is hard to find something that fits theory. Enclosed or infinite designs performs the best according to their ability to confine the unwanted wave produced by the back drivers movement so there must be something wrong about bass-reflex box design but… Why are they so popular? Simple answer: they are always cheaper to build than the enclosed ones. Letting the wave flow out the box DM or wood speker box walls could be thinner just because they do not have to suffer all the back pressure force. What is more: box itself could be smaller because air doesn’t need to be compressed. The main problem about enclosed designs is air pressure getting high while the driver moves back. This pressure acts against the drivers movement, braking the coil and increasing impedance and sending back the cone in a uncontrolled and unwanted way. So if you want a nice sounding enclosed design it must be a big, thick walled, massive braced, fully inside foam dressed box and be aware that bigger than reflex box will result into a small music field mainly because the dirty waves coming out from reflex ports increase distorsion at high listening levels giving you the fake feeling of a bigger but fuzzy soundstage…
… so how will an at least mid-field enclosed high-end speakers looks like?
HUGE (and really heavy).
Stay connected and you will hear it… soon.
Thanks to LittleP for their language support, send me an e-mail if you are interested on the unchecked version of this article just as a useful “Find the 100 mistakes” english learning exercise